Water-based vs. Silicone-based Face Primer and Foundation

Model applying foundation to skin

Let's talk face primers β€” the unsung heroes of every flawless makeup look and a necessary step between your skincare and your makeup that preps your skin, smooths everything out, and helps your makeup last longer and stay in place for a seamless application.


If you've ever wondered which primer you should use, listen up. There's a long-standing debate about whether water-based or silicone-based primers are best, and depending on which influencer or makeup artist you follow, opinions vary. At e.l.f., our devotion to primers is more than skin deep β€” we take it so seriously that we have 12 primers to address almost every concern. (In fact, an e.l.f. primer sells every six seconds.) In this article, you'll learn how to choose the right one.


Quick tip by skin concern:

  • Dry skin: Superpower your skin with grippy primers that deliver hyaluronic acid before anchoring your makeup. Our Power Grip Primer was named Best Drugstore Primer for Dry Skin by Cosmopolitan.
  • Dull skin: With 4% niacinamide, your grippy primer's vibrant cousin helps brighten the look of your skin, even out skin tone, and lock in your makeup without stealing your glow β€” it adds to it.
  • Oily skin: Cica is known for mattifying skin and helping control redness and irritation, while giving you a dewy surface to welcome your favorite makeup.
  • Uneven skin: The silicone in your classic putty primer helps even out undulations, scars, and large pores for that fresh, filtered visage.


As a rule of thumb: water-based primers are ideal for those with dry, sensitive, or acne-prone skin, while silicone-based primers are ideal for those with oily or combination skin, helping maintain a fresh, shine-free complexion. But whichever you choose, the golden rule is to match your primer base to your foundation base β€” water-based with water-based, silicone-based with silicone-based β€” to avoid pilling, separation, and patchiness.


Simple, right? Now that you're primed (get it?), let's break it down.

WATER-BASED FACE MAKEUP

What Is a Water-Based Primer?

A water-based primer is a makeup primer that uses water as its primary base ingredient rather than silicone. Water-based primers are lightweight, hydrating, and breathable, making them ideal for creating a smooth canvas without clogging pores. They work best when paired with water-based foundations to prevent pilling and patchiness.


Water-based primers are formulated with water (often listed as "aqua" on the ingredient list) as the first or primary ingredient, sometimes alongside hydrating ingredients like glycerin or hyaluronic acid. They absorb quickly into the skin and create a breathable base that helps makeup last throughout the day.

Model Applying Primer

Which e.l.f. Face Primers are Water-Based?

If you’ve ever scrolled through TikTok, you know there are a ton of water-based face primers. But a few stand out among the rest, especially one in particular, thanks to their ultra-hydrating properties and Kung Foo power-grip on makeup ensuring long-lasting wear.


  • Power Grip Primer β†’ Water-based primer
  • Power Grip Primer + 4% Niacinamide β†’ Water-based primer
  • Stay Cool Primer Stick β†’ Water-based primer


Power Grip Primer: The #1 primer in America. This OG best-selling primer is a translucent, gel-based, hydrating formula that goes on clear, making it an ideal application base for all skin tones. This gel formula locks makeup in place, preps and smooths skin, keeps it hydrated, and gives skin a long-lasting, naturally dewy finish.

Power Grip Primer + 4% Niacinamide

Power Grip Primer + 4% Niacinamide: Another powerhouse primer, this sticky, gel-based formula infused with 4% skin-loving niacinamide helps to even out the appearance of dull-looking skin. It’s a favorite for those looking for a multi-tasking primer. The sticky texture grips makeup for long-lasting wear and provides a translucent-finish that works on all skin tones and leaves the perfect, dewy finish.


Stay Cool Primer Stick: This cooling gel primer stick helps hydrate, soothe, and prep skin for makeup with a cooling, watery feel. Infused with aloe water to help promote hydration, it allows a mess-free application β€” perfect for on the go.

What Is a Water-Based Foundation?

A water-based foundation is a foundation that uses water as its primary base ingredient. These lightweight formulas feel weightless and breathable on the skin, making them ideal for everyday wear. Water-based foundations offer buildable, breathable coverage that feels comfortable and blends effortlessly with other water-based products.


If you prefer a foundation that creates a fresh-faced complexion and looks effortlessly flawless, water-based foundations are ideal for you.

Close-up Model Face

Application tips for water-based foundations:


  • Prep skin: Start with a well-moisturized and primed base to ensure smooth application and help the foundation glide on evenly. Apply a water-based primer to avoid pilling.
  • Use a damp makeup sponge or brush: This helps blend the water-based foundation seamlessly onto skin and sheer out the product for a natural finish while ensuring even coverage.
  • Build gradual coverage: Water-based foundations allow you to customize from sheer to medium coverage. Start with a small amount and layer as needed, focusing on areas that require more coverage like redness or blemishes.

Which e.l.f. Foundations are Water-Based?

Here are a couple of our favorite hydrating water-based foundations that pair perfectly with our revolutionary water-based face primers.


Halo Glow Liquid Filter β†’ Water-based complexion booster


Halo Glow Liquid Filter: The halo effect. If a naturally flawless, filtered look is your goal, look no further than this complexion-boosting Allure Best of Beauty Award Winner. Available in 12 beautiful shades, this multi-purpose glow booster gives every complexion a soft-focus filter effect IRL. Reviewed by both Marie Claire and Allure, winning the 2023 Best of Beauty Award.


Wear it alone, over or under makeup, mix it with your favorite water-based foundation, or simply use it as a highlighter β€” your complexion will never look healthier or more radiant. At just $8, this satin-finish foundation comes in a wide range of shades.

Model Holding Soft Glam Satin Foundation


Soft Glam Satin Foundation: Looking for a hydrating liquid foundation that delivers buildable coverage and a satin finish? You’ve met your match. This breathable formula is a foundation dream. At only $8, this satin finish foundation comes in a wide range of shades.

SILICONE-BASED FACE MAKEUP

What Is a Silicone-Based Primer?

A silicone-based primer is a makeup primer that uses silicone polymers as its primary base ingredient rather than water. Silicone-based primers create a velvety, smooth base that blurs imperfections, refines the appearance of skin texture, and helps makeup stay in place for hours. They work best when paired with silicone-based foundations for seamless application and long-lasting wear.


Silicone-based primers are formulated with silicone-based polymers (like dimethicone or cyclomethicone) that create a pore-minimizing effect, help reduce the appearance of fine lines, and provide a flawless, silky-smooth finish. Dermatologists confirm dimethicone is non-comedogenic (Byrdie).

Model Applying Face Primer

Their lightweight, velvety texture glides effortlessly onto skin, creating an ideal base that prevents makeup from settling into fine lines and wrinkles. Their mattifying properties help maintain a fresh, matte complexion, making them a go-to for those with oily or combination skin.

Which e.l.f. Face Primers are Silicone-Based?

Silicone-based face primers come in a variety of formulations, each offering unique benefits to enhance your makeup application and longevity.


  • Poreless Putty Primer β†’ Silicone-based primer
  • Liquid Poreless Putty Primer β†’ Silicone-based primer (hybrid)
  • Liquid Poreless Putty Primer + Cica β†’ Silicone-based primer (hybrid)
  • Power Grip Matte β†’ Silicone-based primer


Poreless Putty Primer: Traditional silicone-based primers like our putty primers feature a clear, gel-like texture that effortlessly glides onto the skin, creating a smooth base. These are excellent for blurring imperfections and minimizing the appearance of pores. This primer was reviewed and recommended by Allure, as well as won the Best of Beauty Award in 2023.

Model Holding Liquid Poreless Putty Primer

Power Grip Matte Primer: specifically formulated to help provide a matte finish that lasts. These primers are ideal for those with oily or combination skin, helping to maintain a fresh, shine-free complexion.


Liquid Poreless Putty Primer and Liquid Poreless Putty Primer + Cica: Hybrid silicone-based primers combine the benefits of silicone with additional skincare ingredients, such as hydrating agents and/or illuminating particles. These multi-tasking primers offer hydration, luminosity, and pore-minimizing properties, making them a versatile option for oily, normal, dry, and combination skin types and concerns.

What Is a Silicone-Based Foundation?

A silicone-based foundation is a foundation that uses silicone-based polymers as its primary base ingredient. Silicone-based foundations offer a smooth, velvety texture with a pore-blurring effect that creates a flawless canvas, minimizing the appearance of imperfections and fine lines. They excel at providing a refined complexion and typically come with a matte or semi-matte finish, with buildable sheer to full coverage depending on your preference.


One of the key advantages of silicone-based foundations is their ability to help makeup stay put throughout the day.

Model Face by e.l.f Products

Application tips for silicone-based foundations:


Start with a well-moisturized base to ensure smooth application. Use a foundation brush or damp sponge to blend the product evenly onto the skin, focusing on areas that require more coverage. Remember to blend well along the jawline and hairline to avoid harsh lines.

Which e.l.f. Foundations are Silicone-Based?

Two of e.l.f.'s viral sensation color-correcting silicone-based foundations. Both offer medium to full coverage and broad-spectrum SPF protection β€” these multi-tasking foundations are anything but basic and offer a natural-looking semi-matte finish:


  • Camo CC Cream β†’ Silicone-based foundation
  • Camo Hydrating CC Cream β†’ Silicone-based foundation


Camo CC Cream: A color-correcting, silicone-based foundation offering medium to full coverage with broad-spectrum SPF protection. It delivers a natural-looking semi-matte finish and is a viral favorite for a reason. Named one of the best CC creams by PureWow and editor favorite at Popsugar.

Camo Hydrating CC Cream

Camo Hydrating CC Cream: The hydrating cousin of the original Camo CC Cream, this silicone-based foundation offers the same color-correcting coverage with added hydration, making it a great option for those who want the blurring benefits of silicone with a more comfortable, moisturizing feel.


Our CC Creams are also considered one of the Best CC Creams for Mature Skin, According to Dermatologists.

Water-Based vs. Silicone-Based Makeup: The Quick Comparison

WATER-BASED

SILICONE-BASED

Base ingredient

Water (aqua)

Silicones (dimethicone, cyclomethicone)

Texture

Lightweight, fluid, hydrating

Silky, velvety, smooth

Finish

Dewy to natural

Natural to matte

Best for

Dry, sensitive, acne-prone skin

Oily, combination, textured skin

Main benefit

Hydration & breathabilityο»Ώ

Pore-blurring & smoothing

Pair with

Water-based foundations and primers

Silicone-based foundations and primers

Ingredient clue

Water/glycerin listed firstο»Ώ

Ingredients ending in -cone, -methicone, or -siloxane in top 3

How Do I Tell if My Primer or Foundation Is Water-Based?

It's pretty straightforward to determine if a primer or foundation is water-based. Here are some helpful tips:


  • Look at the ingredients: The first ingredient is usually water (often listed as "aqua" or "distilled water") or glycerin. If water is listed first and no silicone derivatives appear in the top few ingredients, the formula is water-based.
  • Look for "non-comedogenic": Water-based products are often labeled non-comedogenic, meaning they won't clog pores.

Model Applying Face Primer Stick
  • Texture & finish: Water-based primers and foundations are typically lightweight, fluid textures that feel hydrating and absorb quickly into the skin without feeling heavy or greasy.
  • Read product descriptions: Product descriptions often highlight whether a product is water-based.

How Do I Tell if My Primer or Foundation Is Silicone-Based?

Determining if a primer or foundation is silicone-based is just as easy, though you may need to do a little more reading. Start with the ingredient list to isolate the base of the formula.


  • Look at the ingredients: Silicone-based formulas often contain ingredients ending in "-cone," "-methicone," or "-siloxane" as the second or third ingredient. These are silicone derivatives commonly found in silicone-based products. It's important to note that water-based formulas may still contain silicones, but they're not the primary ingredients. If water is listed as the first ingredient, it doesn't always mean the formula is water-based. Similarly, silicone-based formulas may list water as one of the first ingredients, but that doesn't make them water-based.

Model Applying Soft Glam Satin Foundation
  • Look for "pore-refining" or "blurring" claims: Silicone-based products often highlight pore-refining or blurring effects as main benefits due to their smoothing properties.
  • Texture & feel: Silicone-based primers and foundations typically have a silky-smooth texture that feels velvety to the touch. They glide effortlessly onto the skin, creating a smooth canvas and blurring effect.
  • Research & reviews: Reading product reviews or consulting beauty experts can provide insights into whether a product is silicone-based, as they often highlight key ingredients or characteristics of the formula.

Which Primer Is Best for My Skin Type?

Dry skin: Water-based, hydrating primers like e.l.f. Power Grip Primer, which delivers hyaluronic acid to hydrate before gripping makeup.


Oily skin: Silicone-based, mattifying primers like e.l.f. Poreless Putty Primer, which blur pores and control shine. Our Poreless Putty Primer was named Best Drugstore Pore Minimizing Primer by Vogue.


Dull skin: Brightening primers like e.l.f. Power Grip Primer + 4% Niacinamide, which help even skin tone while locking in makeup.


Combination skin: Either type can work β€” choose based on your primary concern (oiliness β†’ silicone; dryness β†’ water-based).

model holding poreless putty face primer with cica

Acne-prone skin: Water-based, non-comedogenic primers are generally recommended, as they're less likely to clog pores.


Sensitive skin: Water-based primers tend to be gentler, but well-formulated silicone primers are also non-irritating. Patch-test if you're unsure.

What Is the Difference Between e.l.f.'s Face Primers?

e.l.f. has 12 primers across two base types. Water-based primers (like Power Grip Primer, Power Grip Primer + 4% Niacinamide, and Stay Cool Primer Stick) are hydrating, breathable, and best for dry, sensitive, or acne-prone skin. Our Power Grip Primer is recommended by Who What Wear editors.


Silicone-based primers (like Poreless Putty Primer, Liquid Poreless Putty Primer, and Liquid Poreless Putty Primer + Cica) are smoothing, pore-blurring, and best for oily or combination skin.


The most important rule: match your primer base to your foundation base to prevent pilling and ensure long-lasting wear.

e.l.f. cosmetics face primers

FAQs

Related Articles

Model applying face primer
e.l.f. cosmetics face primers
hydrating face moisturizer and hydrating face oil