So love it

This is my go to mascara, I stopped using makeup for quite a while and I’m talking about for years, but when I started using make up and I went to go buy mascara, this is the fourth mascara I buy because I can’t find this three for one mascara by elf And it suck. They all suck. They don’t give me the volume that this mascara would give me I loved it please bring it back please I beg you guys.

Clumpy, flaky

It is a nice cheap price but unfortunately it was clumpy, did not go on smoothly and was flaky. With other cheap brands making good formulas I can't justify using this one

Wasn't expecting this!

For two years I've been looking for the "One" mascara thats as good as clinique. But without testing on animals. Must off tried over 10 mascara from 3.99 to 27.99 Either clumps, smudging, no lift or curl? So really didn't think it would be any good, as just bought one for 23.99 (not much to write about.) Well; it stayed on all day no clumps etc. When you put the mascara on it's not caked in excess product! 10/10 Just hope they don't change anything about it.

Best I’ve ever used

This is the best mascara I’ve been used. It coats every lash evenly and allows you to manipulate each lash to where you want it. It lengthens, volumises and thickens your lashes. It sort of coats the lashes, which comes off easily by this magic stuff called soap and water. If you use wipes and cotton wool I would imagine you’ll get sore eyes with the continuous rubbing with abrasives. Nothing more gentle and natural than soap and water and a wash cloth.

Nope, nope, nope.

I really do like the applicator: I have to give it that. But the formula is dreadful. If you can get the mascara to dry without smearing your upper & lower eyelids, you're very skilled/lucky (placing tissues under your eyes and not blinking for a half-minute certainly helps). But your lashes are still sticky, so the lower lashes begin to stick to the upper ones. Clumps form. I'll put the mascara aside for a few weeks, then try it again, forgetting how bad it was. Then it quickly comes back to me why I don't use it! I hate throwing it away after 4 uses, but it's really unusable.

Great mascara!

This mascara has everything I want! The round ball end is great for getting corner lashes! It lasts all day with no flaking or smudging.

Best Mascara Ever!

I got this as a freebie and I love it! I’ve used so many brands and this one is my favorite! It glides on easily and makes my lashes look full, but not clumpy. The wand is amazing! I can get my lower lashes fully coated. And this mascara looks fresh all day!

Hard to use

I've been using this for a while and just can't work out how not to poke my eye out with it or keep the colour off my lids. It's a very weird brush design. If I get it right, it looks nice but I won't buy it again.