Waterproof?

Had to apply multiple coats in order to have mascara on my lashes. I’ve used it multiple times and every single time it ends up on my skin below my eyes and on my eyelids. I was really hoping to find a cleaner waterproof mascara that didn’t smudge, flake, or run.

Great if you like thick mascara and long lashes

This mascara was great, although thicker mascara isn’t really my thing since I like more of a natural look. It lengthened my lashes but somewhat difficult to apply. :)

What happened

I've used this mascara for a few year's, after buying it the first time and loving it, my last 3 tubes seem like different mascara, barely goes on, when I try adding more, even tho there's hardly anything on my lashes, it goes on messy, not clean like it went on before. What happened to this mascara, it's awful now??

It doesn't run

So glad elf brought back their waterproof mascara. Goes on the lashes easily and doesn't make my eyes itch.

Big & Bold

I love a good mascara. I put this one on when I received it although I was just getting ready for bed. I had to try it. After applying a few coats I was very pleased with the coverage and plump it gives my lashes. I went to put on my face lotion and ran my fingers right across my lashes. I thought it would be everywhere but it didn’t budge. I slept with it and didn’t wake up with raccoon eyes. Will buy again

Needs 2 coats but it’s cute

I usually use L’Oreal’s Lash Paradise, so I was comparing this to that mascara going in. I didn’t really like it at first with just the 1 coat as I wasn’t really getting the volume I typically like, and it wasn’t holding the curl. But I tried it again with 2 coats and a slightly different application method, and it turned out a lot better. I do agree with some of the other reviews saying that the brush is really big and can be a bit messy. It’s overall a good mascara, especially for the price! I think I’ll be finishing it.

Best mascara for the price

I am so happy with this brand of mascara. It's the only kind I buy. I would definitely recommend you add it to your makeup routine.

the only waterproof mascara I love

As the title says, this is seriously the only waterproof mascara I've ever used in my life that I has held true to giving me full, thick eyelashes and length. I am so impressed with this mascara and I'll never go without. I actually think I might have to repurchase another one before the 6 month expiration date because it's empty and not just expired. Thank you E.L.F. FOR ALL THE AMAZING PRODUCTS AND EVEN MORE AMAZING PRICES