Black/smoke

love this combo, great color, light shimmer, great combo, needs to be brought back!!

Most beautiful purple 💜

Please bring back the plum eye liner and eyeshadow stick. It's a beautiful color and I have not been able to find a shade alike

This was my favorite eye product. I used the grey smoke eye shadow as liner so soft and smooth. I got compliments all the time. So sad the color is no longer available.

Bring this back

Please bring this product back. I loved the smoke color. Why would you discontinue when so many people want it.

Perfect for travel and home

I'm running out of my last one and had to check the site to make sure they still existed. Sad to see other color combos discontinued.

OG Holy Grail!

I've been using this liner shadow stick for soooo many years, it's one of the first things I can remember ever purchasing from ELF. I use the shadow end for a quick smokey look and as a base for darker grey or black shadows...I mainly use the liner end for upper lid tight lining. This doesn't have much staying power though, so I don't use it when I plan on going out for more than a couple hours. The consistency of both ends of this product are sooo creamy and they glide on amazingly easy. The only thing I'd change about it is the longevity of wear...I wish ELF would make this in a waterproof formula, it would be the most perfect multi use product ever

Olive green discontinued

I bought this but in a beautiful olive green olive, but unfortunately they don’t sell it anymore.

LOVE LOVE

I love this product. I love grey eye makeup. Once I even found grey mascara. I think it is less severe looking on my fair complexion. I use the line and the shadow. Many days I use the shadow as line. It glides on so easily. I have broken both hands so some eyeliner is hard for me. It was discontinued at a place I buy it so I bought all that was left. Glad I can still get it here.