Great

I think this eyeliner is great! I buy it every time I run out of mine!!

Eyeliner

This is nice eyeliner goes on smooth n easy I will definitely be buying more . Hope they come out with color ones would be cut

Works well on eyelids but not waterline. Wears off easily. Glides on, no smudge and black black!

Barely Smudges and Gets the Job Done

Re-buying this, very easy to use. It is not quite as tough as liquid liner, but it works well.

Eyeliner

Works well on eyelids but not waterline. but overall its pretty good for the price.

Creamy No Smudge!

I bought many liners and didn't expect much out of this. Surprisingly good! Glides on, no smudge and black black! Great for sensitive eyes. Not the best staying power, but it lasts at least 8 hours. Better than some high end eyeliner. Stocking up!

My favorite eyeliner of all time

This eyeliner is easy to apply. I prefer a more natural look and I can apply it lightly for everyday or a bit heavier for a night out. Wish e.l.f. didn't discontinue the "Ash" shade, but the black is nice too.

I bought an "intense black" eyeliner that was far from black when I first used it. It was more like a faded black, almost grey. Second time i tried to use it, there was NO INK! Terrible product! I sent an e-mail complaining about that and the management said that they would send me a new one from their office. I never got it!