Medium coverage

I thought this was going to be more sheer or more of a skin tint, but it’s got more coverage than my foundation. That makes it hard for me to believe that the actual amount I’d apply to look normal would be enough to get the spf value claimed. The shade didn’t quite match for me though so if you find a good match it might work better for you!

Shade up

Order fair warm and is too light, recommended to order a shade up

Elf Matte Lipstick, Tea Rose

For the love Christmas, please bring back the Tea Rose Matte lipstick, not the liquid lipstick. 1st the color is not equally the same from the stick vs liquid. A few years ago when I realized it was discontinued I quite literally bought 30, yes 30 from all the websites that sold it. This is my everything color. I have 1 in my work backpack, purse, 2 at home in my drawer I have searched every brand, every cosmetic counter, ulta, sephoria with store help trying to match this color. My sister work in the cosmetic industry, have begged for them to take and re-formulate the color. I went back to reddit to figure out where you got the original sample to even make the color. I have even asked your Bentonville reps that work for walmart to help. Are there samples in your office I could buy. I am down writing a review begging to bring the color back. You may ask why, it is my staple color,y blender color. I dont wear chapstick, I wear this. It goes with dark and light shades, I can even wear it on days I only wear mascara, my no make up days. I could probably write my version of a Dr suess book on this matter stick. I have asked multiple buyers where, how or whonhas the exact match. I have even asked for a brand to offer buying your tel pack woth the formula. Please bring the darn color back. I am 2 years searching and down to 3 sticks remaining. What can we do here? Maybe go back and look at volume and sales. Why was it pulled, where did it sell the best. Possibly a issue with one of the components that made the formula, I would be happy to pay more, triple the price. Or maybe tell me who can make it i haven't already checked, which inwpuld be surprised bc I know cosmetic brands quite well. Please help me. And btw the only reason I wear any other makeup from your elf product line is from this original purchase.

Awesome

I love this product. It is gentle on my skin and is so beautiful. Just all around wow

Inbetween Shades

I would describe myself as a medium neutral and with the reviews I saw I ended up buying shade 10. I loved the coverage and finish of this skin tint but the shade ended up being a bit dark for me. I could see a clear difference between my neck and face. I reordered shade 8, but that shade was way too light. I ended up mixing the two to get closer to my perfect match. I really really hope elf can create a shade between 8 and 10 because I would repurchase in a heartbeat.

A Rare Miss for elf…

I’ve been loving the new spf products like the sunscreen stick and invisible sunscreen/primer so I was really excited for this. I got the free swatch card with a prior order and tried out fair neutral. I usually wear cooler undertones but was surprised to find that this neutral was a close match to my skin tone, other than being a bit too light. The light cool on the swatch card looked very ruddy next to my skin so I went with the light neutral instead. Big mistake. It is the color of peanut butter and absolutely not just a slightly darker version of fair. My gripes with the product are this: It’s advertised as a skin “tint” implying light coverage, but in order to actually wear enough to get the advertised sun protection, you end up getting medium to full coverage. Had I been able to try all of the light and fair shades, I think I may have been able to find a better match or seen enough to forego the product entirely, but only a handful of the shades were offered in the free swatch kit. I think the idea was good, but it may have been more effective to offer options of similar shades, such as a fair and light one, a light and medium one, and a medium and dark one. I have to admit, I’m pretty bummed about this one, especially considering that so many brands are offering a similar product right now. I feel I would have been better off spending my money on one of them instead. Now I have a full sized product that I can’t use, can’t return, and can’t think of anyone I could feasibly offer it to .

This shade was wayyy too light for me to review properly.

Great coverage

One of the best skin tints I’ve ever used. So lightweight yet medium to full coverage! I love it so much