Design fault

I have had 3 and each one the top gets a slight crack in it and keep popping off and product dries up

Terrible

I bought the pencil because it was recommended to me and it turned out terrible. I've only been using the pencil for 8 days and I shake it and very little comes out, it doesn't paint my eyebrows at all 😭

Will not buy again

Received the brow pen along with the Power Grip Matte primer and the Liquid Poreless Putty Primer, which I love very much, however, the the Holy Strokes Micro-Fine Brow Pen was a flop. Shook it to death, place it in hot water and it still did nothing. Not one line, not even a faint one. Nothing. Will not buy again.

Nope

I actually bought two of these, thinking I may have just chosen too light a color with the first one, but the second is no better. Neither one make a discernible mark on my skin at all. I'm so very disappointed.

Great Product but Packaging Needs Work

I bought and loved this brow pencil...even when the spoolie broke off. Because I use it every day, when I went out of town and left my entire makeup bag, I bought another one. The spoolie snapped off of that one even faster. I thought it was a me problem, but I see other reviews here that mention the same issue. I'll use up the 2 that I have, but will probably look for a different brand to try when those are done. :(

Not a fan

I’m soooo disappointed as i thought this would be brilliant like all the other Elf products, unfortunately it’s a strong no from me.

This one is a NOPE

Terrible. Purchased in colour taupe, which is the shade I regularly use in the elf brow pencil. In this product, taupe is so fair I had to resort to writing on my hand to see if product was even coming out. I really like Elf products in general, but this one is miss. Get the NYX brow pencil in taupe insteD

Buildable as described & loving it so far!

I was skeptical to purchase this product from the negative reviews so far but I still really wanted to try from the looks of it online. I was already in the market for a fine tip eyebrow pen for a good price & I was not disappointed with this one! It looks just like the previews do on Elf’s social media. I can understand the reviews stating the color isn’t pigmented or there’s no color at all but the directions say “buildable”. When I first tested the color ‘espresso’ on my hand there was little to no color at all too until I started making micro strokes like eyebrow hairs over eachother repeatedly until the color was exactly what I wanted. Fantastic looking in my opinion! Don’t forget to shake it before using it also with occasional shaking if you’re using it for a while. I have been using mine for over 2 weeks with no drying out issues either. Product goes on super smoothly & doesn’t smudge. I love how tiny the brush is so you can really customize your brows how you want. This works exactly as described so far for me & I will definitely be purchasing again if there’s no further issues!