awesome sauce

it’s awesome.i quite like it.my mom uses the black one i’ve used the brown one and it can double as an eyebrow pencil in a pinch

Blendable

Great for a blended out Smokey eye. Super affordable too

Major breakage

I really tried to make this work, especially when I was just learning to do eyeliner. But it is super hard to use, breaking easily which leads to a major waste of product. It comes off easily too and smudges into eyeshadows if you have oily eyelids. The only use I found for it was to use it for Halloween makeup in drawing a cat nose or something like that. Only positive I would say is it is quite pigmented

Decent for waterline

I use this to line my waterline without the fuss of using a sharpener. There's a bit of transfer to the lower lash line, but it otherwise stays put

Eyeball saver !

Looked for an affordable waterline eyeliner. I avoid "samples" at any stores worried about infections etc. Safest way was to order this creamy eyeliner and the pencil and hope for the best . THIS PENCIL WORKS! I could never get the color or go on my waterline without pressing hard . This glided very well and lasted the whole day ! My eyeballs as safe !

The worst

This is the worst eyeliner I’ve ever used! Smears non stop not sure why they bothered to name it no budge? I want my money back! For only a few more dollars you can buy the revlon eyeliner which will stay on for DAYS with SMUDGING.

Phenomenal

For $5 it's a great eyeliner. I wear to class and after like 8 hours of wear it will fade a bit, but it's so easy to touch up. Def an affordable and wearable product.

Smooth, creamy feel

Overall I like to use this creamy eyeliner as it applies nicely and it allows time for me to smudge it how I like before it dries. It stays on my waterline all day and won’t smudge on the outer corner of my eye throughout the day. I would just like to be able to sharpen it so I can make my lines more precise.