Difficult to use

I got Amethyst. Based on the other reviews I suspect the one I received was dried out and broken, or perhaps it was the color I got specifically. It takes a lot of rubbing to get the product to apply, and it cannot be blended. I think the one I got may have been dried out. It also seems to be loose in the container like the stick broke somewhere during shipping. Because of the thickness of the stick, the difficulty in getting color to deposit, and the inability to blend, this does not work well as an eyeshadow/eyeliner for me.

Chic and effortless

Applies easily and blends so well. Travel friendly and good colour pay off and lasting power

Easy easy to elevate your look

Blends well, super affordable and good to travel with. So easy to use!

Nope

Of all the Elf products I’ve used, this is the only one I was disappointed in. The stick is dry and hard to apply. Almost no blending is possible. To get any color transfer you have to apply lots of pressure - not particularly good on the eye area. Hard pass, especially if you are expecting a creamy texture and good color depth.

Bring back Sapphire and Steel!!!

These are really great and compare to much higher end/ priced eyeshadow sticks. Really want to be able to get the blues back into my hands!

Love

Got for mum and she loved it full of shimmer and shine

Highlight stick

Good product, not my favorite of the elf products but not horrible either!

Too dry/hard to apply

I wanted to love these so bad but unfortunately I couldn’t use any that I purchase. The consistency was too dry and tough to apply. Needs to be a bit creamier.