Favourite drugstore pencil

My favourite drugstore pencil. Applies easily without flaking and lasts for a decent while

Great, natural looking filler

As I am getting older, I feel like my brows are thinning out. I bought this in neutral brown and applied in spots that were thin, then used the spooly end to blend. Works well and is very natural looking. I think next time I would maybe order a different brown shade because this one seems to have a touch of red in it.

Love the design, shame about the colour

I love everything about this pencil apart from the shade, I ordered brunette which is the darkest shade but it has way too much red in it so it just makes my eyebrows look silly. I’ve attached a photo of my equivalent Hourglass pencil in brunette (Hourglass on the left, E.L.F. on the right). So until a darker shade is released I will stick to Hourglass

My holy grail brow product!

This is probably my 10th purchase of this pencil! My brows are already dark and thick. But due to The Late 90s Pencil Thin Brow Epidemic, they're patchy in places. And this is the perfect consistency and blend ability for me. The pencil is SO thin, I love that. It's *just* pigmented enough to payoff without being so pigmented that it's hard to blend. And the dryness of the formula allows for the perfect strokes.

Shade range extremely limited and inaccurate

Just as the title says. I have dark brown (but not black) hair and brows and chose "brunette", the darkest listed shade. It's a reddish medium-auburn at best, not even close to brunette, and looks odd even when fully blended. The product itself is nice and easy to use, but this shade range is an actual joke.

Womp womp

The ‘brunette’ colour is straight up red. I’m so bummed. I look like I have a red rash in my eyebrows when I use it. Wish I’d just stuck to the other brow pencil I was using.

Perfect

Just what I was looking for! I find a lot of brow pencils too thick, but this is just right.

Skinny and precise

The tip was flat upon opening but super easy to use, super easy to apply hair like strokes and usually I would have to switch out to a pen to create a sharp tail but this time I can use on the go no problem!