H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen

$7

Smudge-proof and waterproof eyeliner pen

H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Original Black
H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Original Black
H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Original Black
H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Original Black
H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Original Black
Swatch - Original Black

on orders +

FREE SHIP & 2 MINIS WITH $35+, BONUS GIFT WITH $50+!

What is it: A waterproof liquid eyeliner pen with a precision felt tip for creating thick or thin lines with intense color.

Why we love:

  • Quick-dry, long-lasting formula
  • High pigment eyeliner, smudge-proof color with a matte finish
  • Precision felt tip pen

Key Ingredients:

  • Vitamin E - Nourishes and softens

Keep yourself in line—this waterproof liquid eyeliner makes it easier than ever to instantly enhance and define your eyes. The pen’s fine felt tip delivers intense, deep black pigment that won’t budge—from thin, tight lines to thick, dramatic cat eyes, you have control. The vitamin-infused formula nourishes your lash line and stays put all day for a long-lasting look.

The Cos-Crime Epidemic: In 2023, reports of cos-crime aka "e.l.f.-pinching" hit an all-time high—with the majority of these crimes occurring within the home. Find out more about this epidemic—and how you can keep it from happening to you—by watching the story of one family’s brush with e.l.f.-pinching right here.

“Okay, okay! I admit it! I stole her eyeliner pen and eye shadow but—wow, this stuff really is
Waterproof.” - Charlotte

All e.l.f. products are free from phthalates, parabens, nonylphenol ethoxylates, triclosan, triclocarban, and hydroquinone. All skincare is also free from sulfates.

All e.l.f. products are Vegan and Cruelty Free.

SKU: 81109

What is it: A waterproof liquid eyeliner pen with a precision felt tip for creating thick or thin lines with intense color.

Why we love:

  • Quick-dry, long-lasting formula
  • High pigment eyeliner, smudge-proof color with a matte finish
  • Precision felt tip pen

Key Ingredients:

  • Vitamin E - Nourishes and softens

Keep yourself in line—this waterproof liquid eyeliner makes it easier than ever to instantly enhance and define your eyes. The pen’s fine felt tip delivers intense, deep black pigment that won’t budge—from thin, tight lines to thick, dramatic cat eyes, you have control. The vitamin-infused formula nourishes your lash line and stays put all day for a long-lasting look.

The Cos-Crime Epidemic: In 2023, reports of cos-crime aka "e.l.f.-pinching" hit an all-time high—with the majority of these crimes occurring within the home. Find out more about this epidemic—and how you can keep it from happening to you—by watching the story of one family’s brush with e.l.f.-pinching right here.

“Okay, okay! I admit it! I stole her eyeliner pen and eye shadow but—wow, this stuff really is
Waterproof.” - Charlotte

All e.l.f. products are free from phthalates, parabens, nonylphenol ethoxylates, triclosan, triclocarban, and hydroquinone. All skincare is also free from sulfates.

All e.l.f. products are Vegan and Cruelty Free.

SKU: 81109

H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen

$7

Smudge-proof and waterproof eyeliner pen

Swatch - Original Black

1

FREE SHIP & 2 MINIS WITH $35+, BONUS GIFT WITH $50+!

100% Vegan & Cruelty Free

We are e.l.f. clean, vegan and cruelty free—always.

100% Vegan & Cruelty Free

Average Customer Ratings (276)

Overall4.2
Quality of Product
4.2
Value of Product
4.3

Rating Snapshot

5 Stars
172
4 Stars
46
3 Stars
22
2 Stars
17
1 Star
20

Most helpful favorable review

7 years ago

TeraBean

Very Waterproof; Tested.

Cried for 20 minutes while wearing this eyeliner not one smudge! (Psa; I also squeeze my eyelids together when crying!)

100 of 104 people found this helpful

Most helpful critical review

7 years ago

mellieeee

Not waterproof

Great pigmentation and super easy to form a wing. However, it's definitely not waterproof as advertised. I was outside for 10 minutes in snowy&windy weather and the eyeliner was already beginning to smudge and wear off.

45 of 47 people found this helpful

1 - 8 of 276 Results

BirdieBabySophie

Location

Kentucky

Reviews

1

Votes

0

Fashion Style

Eclectic

Age

18 to 24

Makeup Expertise

Advanced

Eye Color

Grey

Skin Tone

Very Fair

Skin Type

Combination

10 days ago

Waterproof to the Maxx!

I've cried in this eyeliner, ran through the rain in this eyeliner, accidentally slept in this eyeliner, and the most that I've needed to do is a bit of touch-up. I have hooded eyes, so transfer is a huge problem for me with other eyeliners, but this one doesn't do that, it stays put instantly! Had a few problems with earlier batches having faulty nibs and drying out too quickly, but newer batches (as of my review) are all flawless! I love how I can get pretty precise lines and thick lines all with the same pen too! My only ask would be making it a little easier to hold as someone with hand related disabilities or maybe asking for e.l.f to come out with their own stencil tool? :)

Pros - Beauty

Long Lasting, Good Pigmentation, Effective

Best Uses - Beauty

On-the-go, Daily Use

Quality of Product

5.0

Value of Product

5.0

Helpful?

kitttyyykaattt

Reviews

1

Votes

0

1 month ago

LOVEEEE

Super nice and dark. Smooth and lovely♥️♥️ drys quickly

Helpful?

Najla

Location

Phoenix AZ

Reviews

7

Votes

7

Fashion Style

Classic

Age

65 or Over

Makeup Expertise

Advanced

Eye Color

Blue

Skin Tone

Light

Skin Type

Normal

1 month ago

Can go on Superfine, Waterproof

I love that I can use the tip and get a superfine line or hold the pen sideways for a wider line. I find it to be waterproof and removes easily with my cleanser.

Pros - Beauty

Easy to Apply, Lightweight, Great Value, Good Pigmentation, Effective

Best Uses - Beauty

Daily Use

Quality of Product

5.0

Value of Product

5.0

Helpful?

Melzr

Location

FL

Reviews

30

Votes

27

Fashion Style

Eclectic

Age

45 to 54

Makeup Expertise

Advanced

Eye Color

Hazel

Skin Tone

Medium

Skin Type

Combination

1 month ago

Awesome application, Rich pigment, lasts all day!

Rich, opaque pigment that applies easily thanks to the felty tip. Precise lines from thin to chubby, This is a fantastic eyeliner. In a huge pile of liquid liners from high end to dollar store, This one is at the top that I reach for most often.

Pros - Beauty

High Quality, Easy to Apply, Lightweight, Long Lasting, Good Pigmentation, Effective

Best Uses - Beauty

Oily Skin, Special Occasion, On-the-go, Daily Use, Normal Skin, Sensitive Skin

Quality of Product

5.0

Value of Product

5.0

Helpful?

amberhul13

Location

miami, florida

Reviews

3

Votes

1

Fashion Style

Trendy

Age

18 to 24

Makeup Expertise

Intermediate

Eye Color

Brown

Skin Tone

Medium

Skin Type

Sensitive

1 month ago

The Best Eyeliner

I bought this eyeliner for the first time 3 years ago, and i still buy the same one every time!! I've tried multiple eyeliners from other stores but this one is everything, it doesn't smudge, lasts all day, the tip is very manageable and I use it almost every day, and the whole pen lasts 3 months, and for the price it's very worth it.

Pros - Beauty

High Quality, Long Lasting, Great Value, Good Pigmentation

Best Uses - Beauty

On-the-go, Daily Use

Quality of Product

5.0

Value of Product

5.0

Helpful?

Casper123

Reviews

13

Votes

10

Fashion Style

Eclectic

Age

18 to 24

Makeup Expertise

Advanced

Eye Color

Green

Skin Tone

Very Fair

Skin Type

Combination

2 months ago

Long Lasting and Pigmented

This is a great eyeliner especially for beginners since it’s so easy to hold and apply. I never got a chance to properly test whether it’s waterproof but I did notice that it does take a little longer to remove than other liners so I would be confident that it really is waterproof.

Pros - Beauty

High Quality, Easy to Apply, Lightweight, Long Lasting, Great Value, Versatile, Good Pigmentation, Effective

Best Uses - Beauty

On-the-go, Daily Use

Quality of Product

5.0

Value of Product

5.0

Helpful?

CrowsTrinkets

Location

Springfield, MA

Reviews

1

Votes

1

Fashion Style

Casual

Age

25 to 34

Makeup Expertise

Beginner

Eye Color

Blue

Skin Tone

Very Fair

Skin Type

Combination

3 months ago

Amazingly surprised

I tested on my hand and I did a whole day of baking bread to cutting chicken in the afternoon with several hand washes in between. Did not budge! Excited to see how it holds up on my upcoming cruise!

Pros - Beauty

Easy to Apply, Lightweight, Long Lasting, Great Value, Good Pigmentation, Effective

Quality of Product

5.0

Value of Product

5.0

Helpful?

arpita

Reviews

1

Votes

1

Eye Color

Brown

Age

18 to 24

3 months ago

amazing liner!

bought this a while ago and it's the best liner I've ever purchased! so pigmented and does not budge, I've worn this for countless hours before and it really does not budge and because of this it is a little difficult to remove but I don't mind! amazing quality and longevity for the price

Quality of Product

5.0

Value of Product

5.0

Helpful?

1 - 8 of 276 Results